Heels Season 3: Renewal News, Cast Updates, and What to Expect

The short answer: There’s no confirmed Season 3 of Heels yet, but hope isn’t lost. After Starz canceled it post-Season 2 in September 2023, the show landed on Netflix. If it performs well there—and key cast members manage to align schedules—a third season could be possible, though many logistical hurdles remain.

Background and Cancellation

Heels premiered on Starz in August 2021, created by Michael Waldron and starring Stephen Amell and Alexander Ludwig. The show gained critical praise for its nuanced take on small-town wrestling drama, releasing two seasons before its curtain dropped in September 2023.

Starz’s decision to cancel the series surprised fans. Showrunner Mike O’Malley later confirmed they were actively seeking a new platform, hinting that the Season 2 finale was never meant to be the series endpoint.

Netflix Pickup and Revival Prospects

In April 2024, Netflix licensed both seasons of Heels. This opened a door for potential revival, as streaming performance could sway decisions. The platform’s expanding wrestling interest—especially after securing WWE content—makes it a fitting new home.

Stephen Amell even voiced support for a shift to Netflix Originals:

“If there is a hashtag that gets us, we want it to be #HeelsSeason3… the logical step forward would be changing it from a Starz original to a Netflix original.”

Michael Waldron shared that creative talks, including with WWE, are ongoing:

“We often said, ‘Well, s‑‑‑, if we were on Netflix, everybody would be watching this thing!’ … great conversations with WWE, which could potentially become part of the storyline if the show continues.”

Still, major roadblocks linger.

Cast Conflicts and Production Challenges

The main obstacle? Scheduling. Stephen Amell is committed to Suits: LA, now officially picked up by NBC, and Alexander Ludwig leads a new sci-fi drama Earth Abides on MGM+.

Sources highlight that even if Netflix wants to revive Heels, the cast’s availability makes it tricky:

• Amell’s Suits: LA raises scheduling conflicts.
• Ludwig’s new project adds further complexity.
• Reassembling the cast and crew after this gap may be tough.

Community Sentiment and Fan Momentum

Fan forums remain passionate. Many express frustration over how abruptly Heels was pulled. The Season 2 cliffhanger—Jack Spade’s apparent paralysis—remains unresolved, spurring speculation and desire for a continuation.

Even public figures like CM Punk have chimed in:

CM Punk revealed he’s pushing Netflix for a Season 3 renewal.

So, the fandom is alive, and voices are being heard.

Creative Direction—What Could Season 3 Explore?

In interviews, Waldron hinted what Season 3 could address:

• The emotional and social fallout of Jack’s injury.
• DWL’s growth and the “dark side of success.”
• Wrestling narrative synergy with WWE elements.

Waldron specifically imagines exploring what happens when a struggling town suddenly sees prosperity—and the moral and personal cost that follows.

Summary Table: Heels Season 3 Status

| Factor | Status / Consideration |
|————————-|————————————————————————-|
| Official Renewal | None yet from Netflix or Starz |
| Netflix Streaming Deal | Both seasons licensed; opportunity for revival |
| Cast Availability | Complicated due to Amell (Suits: LA) and Ludwig (Earth Abides) |
| Story Continuation | Creators ready to proceed; storyline remains unresolved |
| Fan & Industry Support | Strong from both fans and figures like CM Punk |
| Platform Fit | Netflix’s WWE acquisitions align well with Heels themes |

Conclusion

Despite no formal Season 3 pick-up, Heels isn’t forgotten. The Netflix acquisition gives it renewed life—and if viewers respond, the creative team is ready to fight back into the ring. Still, scheduling conflicts and production logistics pose real hurdles. For now, turning viewership into a revival remains hope’s best lever.

FAQs

Will Heels Season 3 definitely happen on Netflix?

Not yet. Netflix hasn’t greenlit it, but the door remains open if streaming numbers are strong and cast schedules align.

Why was Heels canceled originally?

Starz ended the show after two seasons in September 2023, likely due to budget constraints and strategic shifts toward more global franchises.

When did Heels hit Netflix?

Both seasons started streaming on September 15, 2024, exactly one year after the Season 2 finale aired on Starz.

What storyline could Season 3 explore?

Creators suggest it would tackle Jack’s injury aftermath, the DWL’s rise, the emotional toll of success, and potentially wrestling crossover with WWE.

What’s preventing a third season from being made?

The main barriers are cast members’ commitments to other projects and the logistical complexity of aligning everyone’s schedules.

Are fans still pushing for Season 3?

Absolutely. Community chatter remains vibrant, and even public figures like CM Punk are advocating for the show’s return.